Personal essays, survivorship tips, and honest community from Nicole McLean — breast cancer survivor and founder of My Fabulous Boobies.

The single best question to ask your surgeon

A breast cancer diagnosis can turn ordinary words into a foreign language. Lumpectomy, mastectomy, sentinel node biopsy, reconstruction, margins and radiation may all appear in the same conversation, while your brain is busy noticing the surgeon’s pen, the cold examination room and whether anyone remembered to bring tissues. It is a lot to take in before you have even decided what you want for lunch. Learn more about Philcsolomon.com.

There is one question that can bring the conversation back to your actual life: “If I were someone you loved in my situation, what would you recommend, and why?” It asks for a clear professional opinion without handing over your decision-making rights. You are asking the surgeon to explain the path they think makes sense, including the reasoning, trade-offs and uncertainties.

That wording matters because “What should I do?” can feel too broad, while “Which surgery is best?” assumes there is one universal answer. Your age, tumour type, stage, genetics, breast size, other health conditions, work, family responsibilities and personal priorities all belong in the discussion. The right operation for one person in Brisbane may be entirely wrong for someone travelling from regional Victoria.

A good surgeon will not be offended by the question. They should be able to explain their recommendation in plain English, describe reasonable alternatives and tell you when another specialist’s view would add value. You are allowed to take notes, bring a support person, ask for time and request a second opinion through the public system, private care or your GP.

Why this question works

The strength of this question is that it invites judgment rather than a brochure recital. Surgeons can list procedures, risks and recovery times, yet still leave you unsure which option they would choose in your circumstances. Asking what they would recommend if you were loved by them encourages a more personalised explanation.

It also creates space for the sentence that often gets missed: “The reason I suggest this is…” That reason may relate to cancer control, the location of the tumour, the likelihood of clear margins, the possibility of radiation or the way a reconstruction would fit your body. You can then ask which parts are established facts and which parts involve clinical preference.

You are not asking the surgeon to make the decision for you. You are asking them to show their working, much like a maths teacher who cannot simply circle an answer and walk away. Their recommendation is important evidence, but it sits alongside your values, another specialist’s opinion and the information provided by your breast care nurse.

Turn a recommendation into useful information

After the surgeon answers, gently slow the appointment down. Ask, “What are the benefits of that approach for me?” and “What are the main downsides?” Then ask what could happen if you chose another reasonable option. This can uncover differences in recovery, sensation, appearance, future imaging, complications and the need for additional surgery.

Ask about timing as well. “How soon does this need to happen medically, and what can safely wait while I decide?” is especially useful when you are juggling work, children, caring responsibilities or a long trip to a metropolitan hospital. In Australia, people from places such as Townsville, Hobart or the Riverina may need to coordinate flights, accommodation and follow-up appointments around treatment.

If reconstruction is part of your thinking, ask whether the surgeon performs it, works with a plastic surgeon or recommends delaying it. Immediate and delayed reconstruction have different practical and emotional consequences. You may also want to know whether your private health insurance covers the proposed team and what gap payments could arise. In the public system, ask who will coordinate referrals and what support exists while you wait.

Bring your real life into the consultation

Clinical facts are essential, but they are not the entire decision. Tell the surgeon what your days actually look like. If you lift a toddler, play tennis, work in hospitality, drive long distances or care for an elderly parent, those details affect how you understand recovery. A two-week restriction can mean something very different to a desk worker in Melbourne than to a self-employed tradie in rural New South Wales.

The Australian healthcare system has its own paperwork maze. Your GP may be coordinating referrals, Medicare may cover some services, and a private policy may still leave you with specialist, assistant surgeon, anaesthetist, pathology or hospital excess fees. Ask for a written estimate and find out which costs are predictable and which may change. The Australian Government’s informed-consent principles support your right to receive enough information to make a voluntary decision, while privacy protections under the Privacy Act 1988 affect how your health information is handled.

You can also ask how your records, scans and pathology results will move between services. My Health Record settings and hospital systems can be confusing, especially when you are seeing a breast surgeon, oncologist, radiologist and GP in different locations. It is reasonable to ask who receives each report and how you can obtain copies. A folder, phone note or email trail can save considerable frustration when treatment becomes a full-time administrative hobby nobody requested.

Ask about the body you will wake up in

Surgical consent should cover more than survival statistics. Ask about pain, drains, numbness, tightness, arm movement, lymphoedema risk, scar placement and changes in breast shape. If you are having a sentinel node biopsy or axillary surgery, ask what the surgeon expects to learn and how that result might change later treatment. Nicole’s candid reflection on asking for help captures why practical support after node surgery deserves attention, rather than being treated as an optional extra.

If appearance matters to you, say so without apologising. Wanting symmetry, preserving cleavage, keeping a nipple or understanding how a scar may sit under clothing is not vanity. Your body is where you will live during recovery and survivorship. Ask whether you can see photographs of outcomes from people with a similar body type, while remembering that every result is individual and photographs cannot promise your result.

Australian retailers offer mastectomy bras, breast forms, post-surgical camisoles and compression garments, but availability, fitting services and prices vary between the major cities and regional areas. Some items may be partly supported through state-based schemes, private insurance or hospital programs, while others are paid for directly. Ask your breast care nurse what is available locally before buying an expensive garment online. A soft front-opening bra and a stack of pillows may prove more useful in the first week than an impressive-looking product marketed with dramatic promises.

Make room for the emotional surgery

The physical operation is only one part of what is being changed. A breast may carry memories of sexuality, motherhood, gender, clothing, intimacy and the uncomplicated pleasure of getting dressed without a strategic plan. Hair loss, scars and altered sensation can affect identity in ways that are difficult to explain during a ten-minute appointment. A personal account of hair loss story shows how a visible change can hold layers of grief that do not fit neatly into a clinical checklist.

Tell the surgeon if preserving sensation, feeling comfortable during intimacy or avoiding a particular scar matters to you. They may not be able to deliver every preference, but they can explain what is possible and refer you to a reconstructive surgeon, counsellor, psychologist or sexual health professional. You deserve care for the emotional and relational effects of treatment, not just a technically successful operation.

You can also ask, “What might surprise me in recovery?” The answer may include tiredness that lasts longer than expected, a temporary pulling sensation, difficulty sleeping, changes in body image or a sudden need for help with ordinary tasks. Reading Naira Fernandez’s perspective can offer a wider creative lens on identity and healing, while support groups and peer programs can connect you with people who understand the peculiar comedy of celebrating a successful shower.

Leave with a plan, not just a procedure

Before you leave, ask the surgeon to summarise the recommendation, alternatives, immediate next steps and warning signs. Confirm the operation’s name in writing, who will call you with results, when pathology is expected and which appointment comes next. If the surgeon uses a phrase such as “we will see what the nodes show,” ask what decisions might follow each likely result.

A second opinion is not an insult, a delay tactic or proof that you are difficult. It can be particularly helpful if the proposed operation is irreversible, if reconstruction is complex, if you have a genetic mutation or if the explanation still feels cloudy. Your GP or breast care nurse can help arrange another opinion, and larger centres in Sydney, Melbourne, Perth, Adelaide and Brisbane may offer multidisciplinary breast teams. Ask whether travel assistance is available if distance is a barrier.

Write down the answer to the main question in your own words. “The surgeon recommends a lumpectomy because…” is more useful later than a page of hurried abbreviations. You may also record the appointment if everyone agrees, or bring someone whose job is to listen while your job is to breathe. For a warm, survivor-centred reminder that questions and support belong in the process, you can contact the blog and explore the community around My Fabulous Boobies.

The single best question is powerful because it begins a conversation rather than ending one. It asks for expertise, honesty and context, then gives you permission to keep asking until the plan makes sense. You can be grateful for your surgeon’s skill and still want clearer language, another opinion or a night to think. Those choices are part of informed consent.

Before your next appointment, put this sentence at the top of a notes page: “If I were someone you loved in my situation, what would you recommend, and why?”